Go Back
Homemade pistachio peanut butter in glass jar with wooden spoon and scattered nuts on dark background

Homemade Pistachio Peanut Butter

Revolutionary homemade pistachio peanut butter that combines the sophisticated flavor of pistachios with familiar peanut comfort. This creamy, luxurious spread costs 60% less than store-bought versions while delivering superior freshness and complete ingredient control.
Prep Time 10 minutes
10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Servings: 16
Course: Condiment, Snack, Spread
Cuisine: American
Calories: 95

Ingredients
  

  • - 1 cup dry-roasted unsalted peanuts
  • - 1 cup shelled roasted pistachios unsalted
  • - ½ teaspoon sea salt optional
  • - 1-2 teaspoons neutral oil peanut or pistachio oil preferred, optional
  • - 1 teaspoon honey or maple syrup optional

Equipment

  • - Food processor (7-cup minimum capacity)
  • rubber spatula
  • measuring cups
  • - Measuring spoons
  • - Clean glass jars for storage

Method
 

  1. Ensure nuts are at room temperature before processing. Check food processor blade for sharpness and confirm bowl is completely dry.
  2. Add peanuts to food processor first. Process for 2–3 minutes until they form coarse, consistent crumbs.
  3. Add pistachios gradually while processor runs. Continue processing for 5–8 minutes, scraping sides periodically, watching mixture transform from powder to paste.
  4. Continue processing until mixture climbs bowl sides and natural oils begin pooling at bottom, approximately 6–8 additional minutes.
  5. Add salt and optional oil or sweetener during final 2 minutes of processing. Process until smooth and creamy, additional 2–3 minutes.
  6. Check consistency by lifting mixture with spoon – properly made butter should fall in smooth ribbons. Adjust with additional oil if too thick.
  7. Transfer immediately to clean, dry glass jars. Store in refrigerator up to 3–4 week

Notes

- Natural separation is normal – simply stir before using.
- For ultra-smooth texture, process an additional 2–3 minutes after adding seasonings.
- Cold nuts will create grainy texture, so ensure room temperature before processing.
- Recipe doubles easily but process in batches for best results.
- Store in glass containers rather than plastic for optimal flavor preservation.